Tuesday, January 18, 2022

1/25…Democracy, pt. 1

Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not, either do some thinking about it and report or consider why you haven’t been thinking about it. 

33 comments:

  1. I haven't thought too hard about the relationship between schools and democracy but I do have some thought. I think schools are great at breeding anti-intellectualism, stifling creativity, and making people hate reading which are all a threat to our democracy. Schools and society have put people with knowledge and degrees up on a higher plane of society than people without that, causing people without that to resent schools and people with degrees. A lot of people view authority figures as people who think they are better than everyone else people of their degrees. School contributes to this by making the creating the archetype of the all knowing, all powerful teacher who knows all and cannot be questioned. This is mainly in old school styles of teaching where people are ridiculed for asking questions or made out to be lesser because of their educational status. Sure education is important but the idea of the all knowing all powerful teacher should be dismantled before it breeds more anti intellectualism.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. also I think school should equip students the skills and tools they need to learn more about their world and to change it. Equip them for the future and not now

      Delete
  2. I think that there should be a fine line between school in democracy. There are certain things in education that should be non negotiable and somethings that being in the democracy we live should be able to change. I think that most would agree that school should teach vital skills such as reading and basic math skills. These are things that should be taught not matter what because they will most certainly be use anywhere to be a functioning member of society. However there are things that democracy should be able to change in schools to make them more fitting for the students within them. Especially from the area I am from I know there are many kids that are forced into taking calculus or algebra 2 and often times they end up failing it. The kids do not care about it and they know they will never use it because they are going to go get a job that does not. As this relates to democracy there should be alternative ways and paths for students to chose that can best prepare them for what they want to do either creatively or technically driven. Through democracy and relationships with teachers they should be more like guides to prepare students to what they want to do rather than tell them what they need to learn.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have never really thought about this much up until the most recent governor election. This is the only thing that I know of that I can relate schools and democracy together. In my eyes one of the main reason that Youngkin won over Mcauliffe was because of the comment made by Mcauliffe about parents and how they shouldn't influence what is taught in schools. I had to look up how the state of Virginia elects the board of education and it is through the Governor and approved by the General Assembly. So really, based on my limited knowledge, it seems that schools don't have that much to do with democracy, or at least I don't think. This is a difficult topic sense I don't know too much about it. But seeing how one comment by a candidate about schools fired so many people up, I believe that schools may have more to do or might be having to do with in the near future.

    As a future educator I don't know how much I would want parents influencing what was taught at schools. If you as a parent want to dictate what your child is taught, I'm sorry but then you should be homeschooling. That's my hot take for the day.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have definitely been thinking a lot about the relationship between democracy and education ever since I started taking education courses. When I think about how all American children are legally required to receive some sort of formal education, it seems very obvious that there should be a democratic process when it comes to establishing aspects such as curriculum. Democracy is an interesting concept because in theory it seems as though each individual citizen should get a say in what happens, but we really don't... Is it even possible for that to happen? Something about your class last semester that really stood out to me is the documentary I watched about how certain states hold a lot of power when it comes to writing textbooks. It's very scary to think that what children nationwide learn is in the hands of certain amount of board members and what they deem appropriate to teach. In a sense there is democracy that goes into electing board members, but it seems like we could do better.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I believe that education is the foundation of a strong democracy. Schooling should contribute to forming independent thinkers who question the world around them and are able to discern credible information from misleading or false information. This kind of education will allow people to effectively use the United States' democratic system to promote the best interests of voters. The United States' universal education system was created to shape docile workers who were intelligent enough to perform their job functions but were not taught to question existing structure or authority. Although many aspects of American public education have changed since its implementation, it still teaches children to follow rules, often arbitrary, without questioning their value. This prevents them from reaching their full democratic potential.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I might have thought about democracy and education before, it just depends on what the definition of democracy is in this context. When I think of democracy I think of a government being run by it's citizens. With this definition, I think schools try to promote democracy because the schools I went to (I can't speak for all schools) had little school governments where students were elected as president, vice president, treasurer, etc. The actual school is run by people who were elected for the school board so there is also a democracy there. However in the schools themselves there is a limited amount of freedom. We have our core classes which go beyond what I believe is necessary but we are also able to choose our own classes after those. But in general, students don't really get a say in the school policies because usually a protest or walk out doesn't change much and I think that is where democracy is limited.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I haven't really put much thought into the relationship between democracy and education. I guess when I think of the two together I imagine a government that actually cares about students and teachers and realize that schools need much more than what they usually offer. Improving the quality of education is very much essential and it can consist of committing more of the existing state budget to education, while cutting elsewhere, acknowledging and addressing overcrowding, and raising standards for teachers. Unfortunately we don't live in a perfect world so education isn't invested in fully as much as other things that the government sees as more important. I don't really know if that made sense but when I think of democracy I just think of government, not really individualism.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have not done a lot of thinking about democracy in school. I have never really considered this idea because I have always thought of them as separate. I remember growing up in a school where my voice got lost. It was very challenging to get my voice out. I feel with democracy in the classroom children, can express themselves. They can be allowed to speak out if something is wrong. I perceive that teachers should also be good role models. Teachers should be someone a student can talk to without fear of being embarrassed or patronized. I went to a school where we elected a president of our grade to make choices for us. Students then have a say in what goes on in the school. Pupils use clubs and volunteering to explore life outside of reading, math, and science.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I also feel like, at the same time, democracy is hard in the classroom. Advocating for every child is challenging. With the right time management, it is possible. I hope one day I will be able to be there for a child in a way I wasn't. It is not that I am trying to fill a void but be better than my teachers were.

      Delete
  9. Molly: I would say the most thought I’ve given to the relationship between schools and democracy is during election seasons. We will vote for members of the school board in local elections and often our government will call upon the community to vote on ballot proposals to decide how taxpayers money will be spent in public school systems.

    ReplyDelete

  10. I haven’t done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it but I have thought about it a little. When I think of the word democracy I think of a population run by members of that specific population. As much as schools try to act like schools are a democracy by having student elected officials I don't think they really do. I think that schools in this day and age don’t use the students' voices enough to better the school system. Students are the ones in school who are on the forefront of everything and their voices should be heard. Sometimes I feel like schools only care about money more than about the students and the teachers. I also think schooling isn't seen as that important to the government.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I hadn't done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might or should do with it. When thinking about it, I don't think schools incorporate democracy all that much which could be a good thing. I know that we were able to elect a president and other positions, but other than that I can't think of any other things that relate to democracy. I do think it's important to experience some democracy in school because without that we would have no experience with it.

    ReplyDelete
  12. As we learned in last class, the origin of public education in the United States was to create a functioning political society. This in itself ties schools very closely with democracy in the United States. Personally, before learning this, my ideas of education and democracy were already tied because my teachers, particularly my English teachers, have always stressed that education is an important part of learning to interact with our society critically–especially when it comes to questioning the politics we consume. I also think there's a distinction between the role of education in democracy, and the role of democracy in education. For example, education should prepare students to interact with and improve democracy, but not every process within classrooms needs to be strictly democratic. I’m not saying teachers should be drunk with power or anything, but it goes back to what we discussed in class about how much control parents should have over teachers and schools; professionals are the professionals for a reason.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I have not done much thinking about the relationship between our schools and democracy. But now that I have, my thoughts are that schools are a big part of democracy.There are times when, for example, parents might want to be involved in what is being taught or how a teacher is teaching their children, but with this the teacher won’t have the freedom to teach the way they are comfortable teaching. Along the lines of freedom, children are taught to speak and be quiet when told to. Although it is important that children learn to respect adults, this does limit their freedom of speech, but in the long run they won’t want to express the ideas they have to their teacher or classmates because from a young age they were told not to. Democracy is seen in schools because of the voting of class president, vice president, treasurer, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I think I’ve spent a moderate amount of time thinking about what our schools have to do with democracy, with most of my thoughts concerning the manner in which lessons about democracy and political subjects are taught. With schools being the system responsible for teaching and informing such a significant portion of the children in our country I think there’s a tremendous amount of importance on the content of what’s being taught as well as the “angle” of what’s being presented when it comes to broaching the subject of democracy, and most matters related to politics in general. I believe the relationship between schools and democracy should be that while in school a student learns about our country’s government, democracy, and all other political matters from an impartial position rooted in as much indisputable fact and truth as possible. I think teaching in this way with those objectives in mind would better serve the students by leaving it to them use what they learn to develop their own opinions and inform their choices rather than nudging them to adopt the opinions or ideology of whoever happens to be teaching them. Another aspect of this process that I think is critically important is the prevention of teaching this content with rose colored glasses, which can best be achieved by developing a curriculum that teaches (if not emphasizes in some cases) students about mistakes, inequalities, and injustices that our government and other domestic parties are responsible for as it relates to democracy and other similar political subject material.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I honestly had to Google what democracy in school systems looks like and after doing so, it seems highly unlikely that this could ever happen in public schools. There are far too many kinds of students who each come from very different backgrounds, so the idea that such a broad spectrum of students could each choose the standard of education they're to receive seems unrealistic. Private schools could probably be more accommodating to these ideas, as they typically have more of the same kinds of students and backgrounds. However, if you're thinking about this as a county wide democracy, where the whole area comes together and sets specific standards that everyone is supposed to abide by, it could work if they take into consideration the students who aren't on the same academic playing field as their fellow peers. There are levels of democracy to be mindful of, and as nice of an idea it is, only very mild forms would probably work at this time.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This is something I struggle with wanting to be a future educator myself. Part of me firmly believes that democracy and government should have no part of education. I believe this because I don't think we should be trying to push political agendas on to children (on either side). But then there's another part of me that is torn and believes that we need education to be standardized across the country so that every child receives the same education.

    Also where do we cross the line of democracy and taking away teachers rights in the classroom? We all too often see so many teachers being forced to teach things in ways they don't agree with because their superiors have decided thats whats best for the classroom. I feel like I don't have a set opinion yet on what I think the relationship between democracy and education should be, but I'm leaning towards no democracy.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I never really thought much about the relationship between democracy and education beyond the government having a say in what students need to be taught or what standardized tests they need to pass. And I also believe that the perspectives the government tells public schools to teach are meant to keep students from questioning past and future controversial government actions. And other than that, I’ve never sat down and actually given it much thought. But recently, there’s been an issue going on in my hometown’s schoolboard that’s brought that connection to my attention. Back in the fall, there was a vote to ban ‘inappropriate’ books from our school libraries and there were a lot of strong feelings about the vote both from parents and chair members. The vote said no to banning books, and the backlash from that ended up getting our superintendent fired from his position even though he was supposed to stay on the board until the end of this year. And the chairman who’s taken his place wants to hold another vote to see if they can get those books banned. It’s crazy because all of this happened really abruptly, and if they vote yes on the ban it could negatively impact a lot of students since the books in question mostly deal with racial issues or have LGBT themes. So it’s a bit scary thinking about how much control a single chair member can have in a situation like this, and the whole thing has made it look like school board votes aren’t very democratic at all.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I have thought a lot about democracy and with it associated with education. I don't feel like democracy in schools will happen because kids don't know what they should learn and that's why we have teachers. I do think that students should have a say in what activity to do or when they should do it.I think that we should give kids a chance to decide on what they should learn but to a point. It's all up to teachers on how much they are able to decide.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I haven't put too much thought into the relationship between education and democracy. I know that there is an elected school board who oversees and votes on what should/shouldn't be taught in schools but that just seems unfair because more than likely these decisions are made without taking every students' interests into account. The first thing that came to mind is what is happening right now in Henrico county where my sister goes to school. The governor made a statement that students shouldn't be required to wear masks in school and so teachers are planning to protest this new rule. I feel like that is just one good example of how there is not much power given to teachers to have say in what happens in their schools. I think it's hard to find the balance between how much say teachers have in matters like this but I also think it would make more sense to have educators making decisions instead of school boards.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I have not given democracy in education much thought, mostly because I was never introduced or made a connection between the two but now I can see how they may be connected. When I think of democracy in schools I think of democratic values that teachers try to promote in their classroom by doing things like making sure student’s voices are heard and having shared power between teachers and students. In that sense, I think it is good for teachers to try to incorporate a more democratic style of classroom, although oftentimes there ends up being a disconnect between what they are trying to promote and what they can actually achieve in a traditional classroom setting. I think this is due to the fact that from the beginning of students’ experience in schools they are taught how to follow directions, conform to the classroom, and view the teacher as the “ruler.” Overall I don’t think schools do a great job of reflecting democratic principles to their students.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I know politics plays a huge role in our education system, however prior to now I had never thought directly about democracy and education. However, thinking about it now, I feel as though democracy affects education and education affects the future of democracy. To begin, a lot of the procedures and standards in education are a direct result of decisions made from democracy. On the other hand, aside from teaching the traditional skills that play into having an “effective” democracy (such as reading, critical thinking, and researching), individual classrooms are in a way set up as mini democracies, showing students how things function on a bigger scale. Additionally, a lot of schools have students vote for things such as field trips, homecoming court, and student representatives.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Honestly, before this class, I hadn't done a ton of thinking about democracy, and it's role in education. I had originally done a lot of thinking about ethics, and their role in the classroom, but after the first couple lessons and assignments, I have come to realize that democracy holds a huge role in many different parts of the education system. I believe the most direct form of democracy in education should take place directly in the classroom. As mentioned in the Labaree reading, school could be viewed as a way to build citizens to uphold the democracy of our country. I feel as though if this is the expectation that is placed on students, classrooms should be run democratically, and the students should get a say in what happens. I believe that students should have a say in certain activities, as well as classroom procedures and such. When teachers facilitate a democratic environment in the classroom, I feel as though it promote democratic ideals throughout the entire education system. In my opinion, this allows for ethics to come into play as well, which is another extremely important topic throughout the system.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Before taking Popcultural Foundations of Education last semester, I had not put much thought into the relationship between democracy and schools. Taking that course has given me a much deeper understanding of the issues in our educational system.

    One part of that class that has really stuck with me was watching the documentary Fear and Learning in Hoover Elementary. To me, this documentary not only blatantly pointed out discrimination in our schools and our country, but it showed how our government can directly influence and affect our schools. The documentary was about a bill in the 1990s, called Proposition 187, that prohibited undocumented immigrants from using public healthcare, schools, and social service initiative. A teacher created this documentary to show the students at her elementary school, in the heart of an extremely impoverished part of Los Angeles, and how they were greatly impacted by this bill. It was honestly horrifying to watch because some of the teachers that worked in that same school voted in favor of the bill, a bill that would negatively affect basically the entire school population.

    I honestly don’t know if there is a right or best answer in terms of what school should have to do with democracy, but I think there are too many instances like the bill I mentioned where citizens of a community get to decide the fate of educators, students, and school systems overall that they probably do not know enough about or understand the extent of their actions.

    Abbe

    ReplyDelete
  24. Before coming to VCU, I had not given much thought to the relationship between democracy and our schooling system. As I have advanced throughout the years, I now see that democracy and our schools have a strong relationship. The people that we elect into our government determine what they feel is best for those who do attend school. Individuals are also taught all about democracy throughout K through 12, we are taught what a democracy is, how it operates, what the different purposes of the branches of government are that we have, etc. It is something that I neglected to pay attention to, I knew that it was important, but not the reason why. While I do appreciate democracy being incorporated into our school systems, there are certain times when it does hinder students from learning valuable information. For instance, when we talked about the new Virginia governor giving parents more say so in what teachers do and do not teach their kids can limit what type of education that students receive. It is wonderful that parents get a say so in their children's education but is there such a thing as too much say so? This is anywhere from 15 to 30 students in each classroom and a lot of parent feedback on education to consider when creating lesson plans.

    Aniyah Scott

    ReplyDelete
  25. In all honesty, I haven’t done much thinking about the connection between what democracy means to us and how those ideas might connect or correlate with schools. However, thinking about it now as well as the Labaree reading we did last class, it really got me thinking of how schools are run. Ideally in the democratic equality sphere, every child has the right to an education; however it is not specifically expressed and what is left to the interpretation of the states, government, and counties is the quality of the education the child may receive. All children have the basic human right to an education but not all children receive the same education. Curriculum varries by state as well as federal and county/state funding varies; so how can we say that all children are entitled to a good education if not all children receive the same equal opportunities to learn. Take for example three children who all live in the same state. The child that is from an inner city school would have a vastly different education than that of a child who went to a well funded private school or even that of a suburban school. Money and the market is what drives schools, not democracy. Democracy is the ideal but money is the reality.

    ReplyDelete
  26. When I first think about it, it seems like I don't give much thought about democracy and schooling being related but when taking a step back and thinking about the principles I think should come along with schooling, it has a lot of democratic ideas intertwined in it. Both in the school buildings and out of the school buildings, democracy has immense power. Inside the school, there's it's own democratic system that varies from school to school and even from classroom to classroom. Teachers will allow their students to dictate the outlook of their days or how they get to learn certain topics. Then they get to vote on things things such as pep rally ideas, stuff that goes on around the school and how their education is going to look. Granted most of this freedom comes when you're in middle to high school, however, the free choice and voting ideology that comes from democracy is string in those practices. Then outside of the school building the government hold a bunch of power of the school board and as citizens, we vote on the people we want to uphold our ideas and beliefs of how the school system is ran. If there is someone we feel is failing our system we vote them out and replace them with someone who can do the job correctly. So democracy and schooling are very closely related to one another

    ReplyDelete
  27. Slightly behind the ball from being out but I can not say I have given much thought to Democracy's relationship with schools. Although they are definitely closely related as i'm sure there is democracy and voting into the Board of Education. On top of that politics surely have influence on what can and cannot be taught in school. I would love to learn more in depth how the two correlate though.

    ReplyDelete

1/20…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...