What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any other thoughts?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1/20…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
What do you think the filmmaker is trying to convey about democracy? What was new to you? What did the film contribute to your understanding...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
Can you give an example of an experience you have had as a student that seemed traditional? How about progressive? Please very briefly one o...
I think he brings up a lot of good points regarding teaching, especially regarding "teaching as a window and a mirror" and teaching "against and for things" and "teaching is an enterprise that helps people reach their full humanity". I think these are all poignant statements regarding teaching. I think they are all important and true things tbat should be regarded and meditated on when one is becoming and studying education. I agree with all of the statements he made that I pointed out above
ReplyDeleteI like how Ayers' discusses and talks about teaching but i'm sure that schools are doing that. Schools right now are focused on SOL's and I think we aren't teaching kids to "reach their full humanity" like Ayers' discusses. If we actually worried about kids reaching their full humanity, we might be living in a better world. I like how he describes teaching as "messy" because in fact it is because there is no way of teaching and you can't predict how it will go and you have to change it accordingly but I didn't realize that until Ayers' brought it up which allowed to me think about it differently. Most of the points Ayers' brought up were very valid.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAyers encourages the readers to see the world as it actually is in regards to education. Oftentimes as aspiring educators we want to ignore the negative realities of the institution of education. Ayers reminds readers that education has been used in the past as a weapon to erase the culture of marginalized communities.
ReplyDeleteThis stuck out to me for two reasons: first, to acknowledge and validate the lived experiences of people who have suffered the harmful effects of that weaponization of education which still persists today; and second, to realistically set future educators on the path of participating in what Ayers says is education at its best, education for the sake of helping humans maximize their human experience.
Ayers puts it best where writing that teachers need to learn to think critically for themselves, outside of even their own institution, writing, "this is required of us if we want to teach students who will continue to develop minds of their own".
Ayers talks about teaching in a way that is real and relevant. He discusses how hard it is for teachers to decide what to do in situations. The difficulty teachers have with parents and children regarding the information presented in class. The idea of education now is more about children expressing who they are. I remember sitting down most of the day. Now, teachers have flexible seating to allow children to move around more. Education is less about "uplifting the savages," as a dehumanization school in Australia describes. Students have more opportunities to choose who they want to be. Schools now allow students to tell teachers their pronouns without looking down upon them. I also found the connection of children to piggy banks interesting. Teachers will talk down on students because, in the end, they are getting paid. They do not care if students pass or fail. The detrimental effect of this is ideology can lead children to believe that no one cares. Teaching now focuses more on what is best for the student than a future worker.
ReplyDeleteAyers views teaching as a way of life, a way to be more human and experience growth with others. He sees teaching as a way to better the world one person at a time, and prepare each student to care about whats important. Ayers believes the best educational experiences come from an environment that encourages individuality and embraces differences. He believes there are many ways to be a good teacher, none of which involve totalitarianism. Students are not meant to submit to teachers. I thought it was interesting how he talked about how some teachers view themselves as opposite to their students... this is so backwards! True growth and learning will never happen unless teachers and students can see the humanity in each other and embrace their differences without pinning themselves against each other. Another point I liked a lot is something we have talked about already: schools reinforce social order and prepare children to enter society as contributors. How can we ensure we are bettering our society and communities by starting in our schools? "Education is always for something and against something else." In order to be a good teacher, one must love the world enough to assume a portion of the responsibility for where we (humans) are going in life.
ReplyDeleteThis was Jesslyn
DeleteI like that Ayer talks about the aspects of education in an authoritarian society and in a democratic society. I agreed with and liked that Ayer said, "education ignites initiative and courage" and how teachers should encourage their students to think for themselves and be true to themselves. Ayer had made me realize that education has some negative aspects when he talked about school being like a prison because they are telling students how to think and act.
ReplyDeleteAyer looks at teaching as a moral obligation and believes that teaching should lean more on the democratic side rather than following strict rules and guidelines. He believes that a teacher should know why they teach and what they want to teach. "become a student of your students first" I love the way he says this. He wants teachers to create a student centered environment where both parties are learning from one another and talked about how authoritarian teaching is ineffective and old fashioned. He believes that as a teacher you should know your own morals and beliefs so that you can push other students to find their own."Education is the point at which we decide whether we love the world enough to take responsibility for it and by the same token save it from ruin.." Ayer looks at teaching and education not so much about teaching facts and history but teaching a way of life. He wants teachers who want to teach and believes the most effective way of teaching is making sure that both the students and teachers are taken into account.
ReplyDeleteBella-Sky
DeleteAyers talks about teaching, and the education system in general, in an informed, analytical, and fairly critical way. He doesn’t shy away from touching upon and discussing issues he feels are present in the education system, such as the danger of dehumanizing students and parallels he draws between behaviors teachers engage in within the classroom and the actions of a ruler or dictator, which he dubs “authoritarian education”. Ayers has an interestingly holistic approach when it comes to the topics he makes connections to while sharing his thoughts about teaching; considering and implementing many different topics and concepts into his understanding of teaching, which serve to help outline the realistic negative possibilities and implications that the current school system and commonly practiced methods of teaching can have on students. One concept that is fairly new to me brought up in this reading, which was also discussed in class to some degree, was the concept of teaching about the world in a realistic and useful way rather than worrying entirely about sticking to an agenda and remaining within the lines of delivering a lesson that just gets the job done. I believe Ayers expresses this concept very succinctly when he writes “I want my teaching to mean something worthwhile in the lives of my students and in the larger worlds that they will inhabit and create”.
ReplyDeleteKira VanSteenburgh: I think what Ayers said about teaching is what teachers should strive to do. Unfortunately with my experience in school teachers teach a specific plan regarding only school smarts. It seemed like they didn’t care what type of person you were at the end of the year. Ayers style of teaching takes morality and ethics into play. He feels that teaching “helps human beings reach the full measure of their humanity”. With that perspective students will feel more free. Reaching full human potential encourages questioning, debating, making choices for yourself and much more which is healthy because not everything is black and white. I think the points he made would be very helpful for teachers and students if the schools took them into account.
ReplyDeleteAyers treats education throughout his writing as a human right. He states and addresses repeatedly education as a right, not a privilege. At the same time, he is able to acknowledge the damage that educational systems can do if they work to breed conformity and complacency rather than creativity and independent thinking. He uses the example of schools being used to force native people into abandoning their traditions and beliefs.
ReplyDeleteAyers’ talks about teaching in an idealistic way. In a perfect world the way he describes teaching would in fact be most effective. Ayers’ talks about totalitarianism in a way that can relate to school, the idea that teachers are the “supreme leader” and that the masses (students) are expected to listen with no thought or question of their own. I also got a new understanding when he says that “Schools do not exist outside of history or culture, of course; they are, rather, at the heart of each”. To me this meant that the heart of our society stems from how the school system teaches. A school system in a dictatorship led country will be taught differently than a school in a democracy. I think that this better helped me understand the enterprise of human teaching can be very much affected by exterior variables.
ReplyDeleteCade Dressler
DeleteWhat stood out to me the most while reading the article was the constant talk about schooling and how it can be dehumanizing. Many are just going through school because they are supposed to. At a point in the chapter Ayers mentions how a young student feels as if they are a tourist in their own life while at school. The authority controls what she learns. The way Ayers talks and uses all of these metaphors is a little difficult to keep up with but the way I was reading this is how in the dehumanization feeling some schooling gives, these students don't feel they are being taught more just being given information. So what I got from the article is that Ayers is saying teachers need to think in a freely. Be creative, keep changing and find what is right for you. This idea of teaching freely and not having a strict code or form helps not only you but your students learn to develop and form their own minds.
ReplyDeleteW. Ayers puts on blast the way we, as a society, have shaped education into what it is today. Not every school is the same, but most schools are purely test driven; how well do the students retain the facts and information given. Paulo Freire says every person's true vocation is the task of humanization. Now, because that's the task, what's being suggested is that the opposite, dehumanization, is being practiced or is a possibility. I'd say based on the way the Australians created schools to "civilize the beasts" (remove every ounce of native-ness from the aboriginal children and how the nuns decided to beat the sexuality out of two women, dehumanization has been practiced in some form in a lot of areas worldwide. Both parties were doing things "for their own good" but at what cost? That's something Ayers focuses on in his ideals for a more democratic approach to education, rather than authoritarian. He wants teachers to figure out why they're teaching and what they're teaching against, he wants teachers to push towards freedom, enlightenment, protection of the weak, compassion, and love. Ayers preaches to stand up for what's right, ask questions, and for the nourishment of yourself and others.
ReplyDeleteW. Ayers puts on blast the way we, as a society, have shaped education into what it is today. Not every school is the same, but most schools are purely test driven; how well do the students retain the facts and information given. Paulo Freire says every person's true vocation is the task of humanization. Now, because that's the task, what's being suggested is that the opposite, dehumanization, is being practiced or is a possibility. I'd say based on the way the Australians created schools to "civilize the beasts" (remove every ounce of native-ness from the aboriginal children) and how the nuns decided to beat the sexuality out of two women, dehumanization has been practiced in some form in a lot of areas worldwide. Both parties were doing things "for their own good" but at what cost? That's something Ayers focuses on in his ideals for a more democratic approach to education, rather than authoritarian. He wants teachers to figure out why they're teaching and what they're teaching against, he wants teachers to push towards freedom, enlightenment, protection of the weak, compassion, and love. Ayers preaches to stand up for what's right, ask questions, and for the nourishment of yourself and others.
DeleteFrom the reading, it can be inferred that Ayers believes that school should have more ethics involved in it and I completely agree. He sees school as a dehumanizing experience, taking away the free thought and liberation from students and turning them into docile and domesticated people in the capitalistic world. On page 6, he talks about how education is always for something and against something else and can never be truly neutral. With the origins of education, they were a way to overthrow the native people and were against their culture, self-determination, and resistance. Fast forward to now, education at its deepest level either stands for freedom and liberation or stands for subjugation in its many forms. Ayers wants teachers to challenge that and think/teach for themselves and not the institution they work in.
ReplyDeleteI really like Ayers’ idea of teaching being about helping students “reach their full humanity”. I’ve found that a lot of my classmates who are going into education have similar ideas about teaching. Most of us are focused on encouraging future students in any way we can and helping them grow as people. And this can’t happen if we just teach what we’re told to and force students to only obey and conform. I thought it was interesting that Ayers called this style of teaching authoritarian, but it applies perfectly; students are only allowed to be listeners and they’re only allowed to view something the same way their teacher does.
ReplyDeleteAyers brings up some really eye-opening thoughts on education and the relationship it has with the humanistic nature of teaching. He pushes the idea of humanization and dehumanization and how sometimes there isn’t a differentiation between the two. He encourages teachers to not only become the student of the student, but to understand the path that is set for them and never take it as something as serious as people make it out to be. Challenge yourself and others in teaching and just have fun with it. That’s kind of what I got from the chapter.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed how he started by bringing up the full potential of what education can be and can mean; how teaching and education "helps humans reach the full measure of their humanity" before then diving into the dangers of education ran by authoritarianism. It expresses very well how some democracy is necessary in education by showing the dangers of when it is not present. We're not educating the next generation to their full potential when we are spoon feeding them specific narratives purposely diminishing free thinking. The world is faced with problems such as global warming that will only be solved by innovators and so we need to prepare the next generations to be able to think for both themselves.
ReplyDeleteI feel as though Ayers sort of encapsulated the way I think of teaching and the education system throughout this chapter. By starting out with describing teaching and the modern education system as an "authoritative style of government" rather than following a democratic model, he really showcased the flaws in the system. As we have been discussing, democracy is an ideal, yet very difficult to achieve, and by saying this, Ayers showed one of the reasons why a democratic society is so difficult to achieve and maintain. I also really enjoyed how he spoke about teaching being based in ethics. Throughout the semester so far, I have been making connections about how the material we have looked at shows that everything about the education system is, or should be, rooted in ethics. I feel as though ethics, equality, and equity are the most important pillars of education, and I appreciate how he pointed out that the education system is kind of broken because of the lack of ethical practices. One example that he used that really stood out to me was standardized and other testing in school. I agree with his argument and feel very strongly that by working towards a test or other certain standards, teachers are doing an extreme disservice to students and their families because it takes away the passion and love for knowledge, and creates robots who just remember facts for tests.
ReplyDeleteMolly: I really liked how real Ayer’s was in his writing. He maintains a realistic outlook on how education is now, while also romanticizing what the intention behind teaching should be. He addresses the lack of encouragement towards individual thought in the students and continually critiques the education system. I’m glad that he didn’t shy away from noting the negative attributes of a subject he feels so passionately about. He feels the role of a teacher can be a very powerful and influential one, so he takes it very seriously. He urges other teachers to do their jobs for the benefit of their students and help them to become their best selves, rather than approach it in a very dictatorial way.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed this chapter because what Ayers tries to do is talk about teaching in the realist way possible, in a way that some people try to ignore. I love how he started with "Teaching at its best is an enterprise that helps human begins reach the full measure of their humanity." What he is trying to say is that education is the forefront and start to a person to becoming more human and educated. I also agreed when he said in order to work in teaching a person must have grace and actually no the purpose of what they are doing.
ReplyDeleteI 100% agree with the idea that Ayers was expressing about kids needing more opportunity to help children "reach their full measure of humanity". However I feel his view was very romanticized. In a perfect world children would get the opportunity to grow as tiny humans figure out who they are and who they want to be. But he very harshly criticized standardized testing, which I don't think is fair. Don't get me wrong, I agree that teachers are forced to put too much emphasis on standardized testing that can take away a lot of opportunities for other things and create children who only care about testing skills. However I think standardized testing/learning is very important especially when we are talking/looking at schools of different social economic classes. ALthough these standardized testing has a lot of flaws it helps equalize the playing field.
ReplyDeleteI don't think its a black and white thing and I have no idea what the answer is when it comes to standardized learning/testing. All I am saying is it serves a purpose and it would be unfair to non privileged groups of children if we wiped it completely out of schools systems.
Ayer mentions that teaching is a way to teach others about humanity. The article also explains how teaching in our schools are realistically. Too often I believe that the intentions of teaching is lost due to greed and power just like democracy itself. The intentions of these two things started off in the name of humanity and has been lost as time has passed. This article has also shown me that what we define as morality is always changing. In the past there are things that have been deemed as "moral" or at least tolerated that would be completely unacceptable in our society today. In the future there will be more changes to the way we perceive morality and what is acceptable and what is not and that will always affect what we teach humanity as to others.
ReplyDelete-Aniyah Scott
I thought Ayers’s way of talking about teaching was interesting and not unlike the embodied view of what we think teaching and teachers should be like. Ideally we all want teachers to inspire, enlighten and push their students to accomplish new goals, to help lead their moral and ethical compases while simultaneously encouraging their students to think for themselves and establish their own ideas and beliefs; in other words Ayers believes “a teacher [should be one] that extends the hand of possibility.” However, Ayers also states that on the flipside, democracy in schools has also had an authoritative essence about them. Ayers argues against this as well as the dominating and repression of individual thinking. Ayers states that education is also a mirror and window to the social world around it and raises the question to teachers; who is it that they are teaching for and what is it that they are teaching against? The quote that resonated with me was when Ayers stated that a “qualified teacher” can pass a simple test, period; but that doesn’t necessarily mean that that “qualified teacher” is a good teacher.
ReplyDeleteI like the way that Ayers describes the importance of teachers knowing what they are teaching for and what they are teaching against. He brings up the point that education can be both humanizing and dehumanizing and describes them saying “the twins clash and struggle, becoming impossibly entangled and difficult to separate.” I think this is a good point because the reality of education is that the system can be dehumanizing but it is the teachers and students together who can bring out the best of humanity in each other. It is the teacher’s choices that can bring about this humanization and when teachers know what they are teaching for and against, these choices they have to make become more clear.
ReplyDeleteI was really interested in the way Ayers talked about teaching. The part that stuck out to me the most was how teaching must have a distinct purpose both for and against different ideals. I thought the examples he brought up, for example authoritarian style teaching, helped me grasp the concept and understand further what he meant by teaching for something and against something else. I thought excellent points were brought up about the dehumanization of schools and how the system teaches students to conform to the mass and not form their own opinions, whether intentional or not. I think that’s one thing I picked up from this chapter when looking back on it: whether people realize it or not, every action is intentional, so we have to be mindful of how we speak to our students, how we treat them, and ultimately how we teach them.
ReplyDeleteAbbe
There was a lot of mind-openers that really make you think about why schools are set up the way they are, Ayers really drives you into what it truly means to teach especially when society makes it so hard to do so. A lot of inspiration that motivates any prospective educator. He really expresses his humanistic way of teaching. Teachers aren't meant to simply instruct and reprimand, but instead they should inspire students to learn and grow.
ReplyDeleteLooked back and realized this was sent through email and not posted due posting technical difficulties earlier in semester.
Delete